Pluto Volume 2 Postscript : The Birth of Pluto by Makoto Tezuka : Visualist It was the winter of 2002. I was given a proposal saying that Naoki Urasawa wanted to draw a manga based on "The Greatest Robot on Earth," from Tetsuwan Atom. "Really? A manga remake of a classic manga? And by a popular artist?" I was honestly somewhat appalled, with all due respect to Mr. Urasawa. Now I'll admit, that given April 7th 2003 was the birthdate of Atom in the original manga, it would have worked well as a tie-in for such a momentous occasion. I don't particularly want to treat my father's works like just some work of fine art. I want them to be widely read and enjoyed by people in any generation. And if giving them rebirth into a new media will help achieve that, I'm all for it. It's not as if no manga artist has ever done their own rendition of an Osamu Tezuka manga before. Over 100 artists drew their own version of Atom in an art exhibit entitled "My Atom." But these were all homages or parodies, and while they might have maintained the spirit and entertainment of the original work, you'd be hard-pressed to value them independently of their base. I figured that this project would hold true to that stereotype. However, this was a serious manga that would be serialized in a magazine, and eventually collected into volumes and sold. When asked of my opinion of the idea, I replied that it might be a bit premature. I figured that someday another artist would do a remake, but certainly not timed to coincide with the birth of Atom. There was a new TV anime series in the works, as well as several other events. I supposed that if it were lined up among all of those, it would be received negatively, as just another money-making spin-off created to milk the occasion. In other words, as the original author's estate, I politely declined. When most people would have realized it wasn't the right time yet and given up on the idea, Mr. Urasawa did not. He asked if I would be willing to meet with him and see some rough drafts and settings that he was working on. He wanted to give me a presentation. Well, this guy is serious. I'd better hear him out. After taking some time to think about it, I finally decided to meet with him. No doubt Mr. Urasawa realized that he didn't stand a chance; he justed wanted to show me what his ideas were. However, with me, the act of "meeting" an author is, in a way, a form of "consent." It meant that I was willing to take responsibility for bringing this idea to the world. There would probably be a segment of Osamu Tezuka's hardline fans that would protest the manga, but I was willing to face this criticism together with the author. I met Mr. Urasawa and his producer Mr. Nagasaki in a bar in Ginza on March 28th 2003, and we talked late into the night. Urasawa excitedly told me how "The Greatest Robot on Earth" was the first manga he ever read, and that it would be the basis for his work. I was ready to accept the proposal even before being told the basis, but at this point, I made my own condition. That this manga would be drawn unmistakably in Mr. Urasawa's style and pacing. You see, the sketches and characters he had shown me on his pad were still restrained somewhat, perhaps out of respect for Osamu Tezuka's original designs. Atom was the exact same Atom we all knew, and Gesicht had the same face as in the original... If we're going to do this, I want to see a manga in Naoki Urasawa's style. And so I requested that he rethink his character designs. Now, I'd had a few drinks in me by this time, and so I was somewhat more forceful and bothersome about it than I might have been. I told him that nobody who had drawn Tezuka yet had attempted to truly take him head-on. I would be the judge to assure a fair fight, so he could do his best against the original author. It wasn't hard to imagine that this is where Mr. Urasawa's imagination truly started to take over. I was regretful that I acted so childishly at the time. And so, as a makeshift apology, in my powers as judge of this competition, I decided to allow Naoki Urasawa the first victory of the war. This isn't a competition about which one is better at drawing manga. It simply means that he challenged Osamu Tezuka head-on, and didn't lose. For that alone, he is to be commended. But the battle is not over yet. To all you readers, I hope that you will continue to witness this battle with sweaty palms and heightened anticipations, for this is a battle between two first-class entertainers with nearly unlimited firepower at their disposal.